I failed. I caught a plane

| 3rd February 2010
A plane ready for boarding
Thousands of miles by train, coach, bus, boat and foot and, at the last hurdle, Ewan finds that there's no way to cross the Tasman Sea except on metal wings...

My heart sank a little as I booked the flight from Sydney to Christchurch. My flight across the Tasman Sea to New Zealand will probably have as much of a contribution to global warming as a train from London to Irkutsk, or a passenger coach travelling almost 1 and a half times around the world.

It wasn't for lack of trying. In the last month, I've made about a hundred calls to marinas, port controllers, even nautical bookstores, searching for that elusive cruising yacht that might want crew for the trans-Tasman passage.

Elusive options

There were tantalising hints and leads. One yacht left just as I arrived. A private powerboat was willing to take me, but its footprint was probably massive. 

The rough nature of the passage and the lack of leads also lead me to investigate cargo ships. Though only a handful of shipping companies carry passengers, one-man-show Hamish, of Freighter Travel, liased with them for me. I had a couple of almosts, and they sounded luxurious - 5 days at sea, my own cabin, arriving at Nelson, but these passages were snapped up by others as soon as they were offered. 

So it's the plane. A necessary evil - if I wasn't committed to starting university again in March this year, I would have held out for an ocean voyage. But this time I didn't have the luxury of waiting.

Airlines under the microscope

Booking the plane didn't mean giving up my desire to keep my emissions as low as I could. Some of the carriers helpfully displayed their aircraft models online so I could check their fuel efficiency on the detailed (if optimistic) flying calculator site atmosfair; I called the ones that didn't to check. I chose to fly to Christchurch, which, surprisingly is slightly closer than Auckland is from Sydney.

I also got to witness the disingenious greenwashing tactics of the airline I did choose. First they ignored the Radiating Forcing Index on their CO2 emissions at altitude, and thus underestimated the real impact of flying by a factor of around two. Then they offered to offset this impact of my flight for a mere 3 Australian dollars by supporting a company that captures landfill methane emissions - a niche but vital public good that could and should be underwritten by any sane government, not propped up by charity.

I contacted the airline with my queries about their offsetting program, and haven't heard back yet. It seems our planet's climate remains low on the priorities of some  companies.

Mode Journey Emissions calcs Total emissions
Coach Canberra - Sydney 287 km x 29g CO2 per passenger kilometre 8 kg CO2
Plane Sydney - Christchurch 2327 km x 186g CO2/pkm 433 kg CO2
  TOTAL 2614 km 441 kg CO2

Equivalent emissions if I had got a passenger berth on a cargo ship: between 12  -  248 kg CO2!

It's very difficult to be precise – this all depends how you want to factor in the space or weight that extra passengers are travelling. If one just counts oneself as extra weight, passengers on cargo ships are very fuel efficient – to the tune of around 2 grams of CO2 per km. As I've noted before, passengers need infrastructure too, which could be seen as taking the place of tonnes of cargo, and this could push the emissions factor up much higher. It's still a niche market though, and could benefit a lot from economies of scale. This is one of the main reasons why I was ready to support it.

(Other emissions factors are from Defra, with a radiative forcing index of 1.9 applied)

No plane, no problem in South East Asia...
Ewan travels south through Laos and Thailand, discovering a landscape that speaks of the awkward throes of industrialisation...
Short haul flights not the problem says climate watchdog
Long haul leisure flights the main driver of aviation emissions, says report that believes Heathrow airport can be expanded without breaking the UK's carbon emissions targets
Airlines admit carbon reductions to come from offsetting
Aviation sector wants to avoid a closed trading scheme and forced carbon emissions cuts
Using art to highlight the madness of Heathrow
The plight of a village set to be demolished to make way for Heathrow's third runway is the inspiration behind Hester Berry's exhibition of paintings on show in a London gallery

More from this author


The Ecologist has a formidable reputation built on fifty years of investigative journalism and compelling commentary from writers across the world. Now, as we face the compound crises of climate breakdown, biodiversity collapse and social injustice, the need for rigorous, trusted and ethical journalism has never been greater. This is the moment to consolidate, connect and rise to meet the challenges of our changing world. The Ecologist is owned and published by the Resurgence Trust. Support The Resurgence Trust from as little as £1. Thank you. Donate now.