Congo massacre case prompts call for crackdown on Canadian mining giants

| 11th November 2010
Soldier in the DRC

Canadian mining company Anvil is alleged to have provided logistical support to the Congolese military

Canadian authorities urged to bring in ethical guidelines for extractive industries as Anvil Mining faces court case for alleged role in the killing of 70 people in the Democratic Republic of Congo

Canada risks tarnishing its reputation for human rights unless it legislates against the overseas activities of the large number of mining companies based in the country, say campaigners.

Around three-quarters of the world's mining and exploration companies have their head offices in Canada, with the sector contributing more than $39 billion to its GDP. However, its record for humans rights is poor. Nautilus Minerals was recently accused of ignoring indigenous opposition to its plans for deep-sea mining in the coastal waters off Papua New Guinea. Northern Dynasty Minerals is involved in a proposed gold mine that threatens Alaska's wild salmon industry.

This week a class action was filed in a Montreal court against Anvil Mining Ltd, accusing the company, by providing logistical assistance, of playing a role in human rights abuses, including the massacre by the Congolese military of more than 70 people in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) in 2004.

The class action, brought by the Canadian Association Against Impunity, alleges that in October 2004 Anvil provided trucks, drivers and other logistical support to the Congolese military to help them counter an attempt by a small group of rebels to take over the town of Kilwa, a key port for Anvil’s operations. Anvil’s vehicles transported Congolese soldiers, as well as civilians who were allegedly taken outside the town and executed by the military.

Anvil Mining, which operated a copper and silver mine in the DRC, denies the allegations of wrongdoing and says it intends to defend itself. A legal case brought in the DRC failed to result in any prosecution, with a UN report later citing the case as a prime example of how justice is not always done in the country. Campaigners say the Congolese victims have been left with little choice but to file the court case in Canada because of the lack of any other way of seeking justice against an overseas company.

'We must continue to fight against impunity. The victims’ families have never lost hope of seeing justice being done,' said Emmanuel Umpula Nkumba, executive director of ACIDH, a Congolese advocacy group that has been supporting the victims.

Ethical mining bill failure

An ethical mining bill, recently proposed by the Liberal opposition party, would have required mining companies based in Canada to adhere to environmental and ethical guidelines when operating overseas. It was narrowly defeated in a vote last month, however, with strong opposition from Conservative MPs. The mining sector claimed the bill would have seen it lose competitiveness against companies based in countries with weaker human rights and environmental standards.

'Passing C-300 would have boosted Canada’s national reputation and demonstrated that we take human rights seriously,' said Alex Neve, secretary general of Amnesty International Canada. 'The message we are now sending to victims is that a double standard will prevail - one standard for operations in Canada and one for negligence abroad.'

Karyn Keenan from NGO Halifax Initiative in Canada said that while it will not stop human rights or environmental abuses, the bill would have prevented mining giants that violated guidelines from getting government support, such as export credit. She said support was growing for a bill: 'I would say that it's highly likely that similar reform efforts will be made in the future. They are badly needed.'

Campaigners said they hoped the class action being brought against Anvil Mining would set a precedent and send a message to Canadian companies that they 'cannot enjoy impunity if they take part in, or benefit from, violent crimes.'

Useful links
Background on the case against Anvil Mining

UK and USA retailers join boycott against Alaska's 'dirty gold'
Leading jewellery outlets including Fraser Hart, Tiffany & Co and Beaverbrooks say they won't use gold from London-based Anglo America's proposed mine in the Alaskan wilderness
How deep-sea mining could destroy the 'cradle of life on earth'
As Papua New Guinea gives go-ahead to a Canadian mining company to dredge its coastal seabed for minerals, critics say environmental assessments have been inadequate, local objections ignored and new species of life could be extinct before they have even been discovered
BP and Shell face new shareholder revolt over tar sands
Investors want oil giants to answer questions on their involvement in the environmentally damaging extraction of oil from tar sands
A melted Arctic: gold mine or honey trap?
As the melting Arctic ice cap opens a new ocean to the world, governments and private speculators are rushing to cash in on lucrative resource deposits and shipping lanes. But they may find these virgin waters a dangerous place to do business…
Throw Canada out of Commonwealth for climate record
Rising emissions and support for tar oil sands leads prominent figures to call for suspension

More from this author


The Ecologist has a formidable reputation built on fifty years of investigative journalism and compelling commentary from writers across the world. Now, as we face the compound crises of climate breakdown, biodiversity collapse and social injustice, the need for rigorous, trusted and ethical journalism has never been greater. This is the moment to consolidate, connect and rise to meet the challenges of our changing world. The Ecologist is owned and published by the Resurgence Trust. Support The Resurgence Trust from as little as £1. Thank you. Donate here