'Cracked' nuclear plant to shut down

| 28th August 2020 |
Hunterston B nuclear power station

Hunterston B nuclear power station. 

Wikipedia
Hunterston B power station in North Ayrshire will move into the defuelling phase no later than January 7, 2022.

Having a final closure date in sight is a hugely significant step in Scotland’s transition to clean, green energy.

A nuclear power station which had been forced to reduce output in the last few years because of cracks in its core will begin the decommissioning process by 2022.

Hunterston B power station in North Ayrshire previously had an estimated decommissioning date of 2023, with “a plus/minus two years proviso”.

On Thursday, operator EDF Energy announced the plant would move into the defuelling phase no later than January 7, 2022 – subject to an inspection next spring and regulatory approval for the final six months.

Dirty

Construction work started on the site in 1968 before it opened and began generating energy in 1976. Cracks were discovered in the core of the reactor in 2018 with electricity generation expected to fall by 40 percent at the time.

Friends of the Earth Scotland’s director Dr Richard Dixon said: “While we’d rather the reactors never restarted, having a final closure date in sight is a hugely significant step in Scotland’s transition to clean, green energy.

“The Hunterston reactors were supposed to shut nearly 10 years ago and their cracked cores show that they are well past their sell-by date.

“Restarting the Hunterston reactors is definitely not worth the risk. Most people in Scotland will not even have noticed these reactors at Hunterston have been offline for most of the last two years, as the expansion of renewable energy has made up for the difference.

“The Scottish and UK Governments should be investing in building the renewable energy economy, creating decent green jobs and delivering a just transition for workers and communities as we move away from dirty energy.”

Clarity

The remarks were echoed by Scottish Greens MSP Ross Greer who said: “I’m delighted that our calls to decommission this cracked, ageing nuclear relic have been heard. 

“The complex work of shutting down Hunterston will provide jobs for the workforce for years to come, but it’s vital that work on a long-term transition plan for the Ayrshire economy starts now.

“It’s essential that both governments put in the effort to ensure another community in the west of Scotland isn’t abandoned when a major employer closes. Turning Reactor 3 back on for six months is a completely unnecessary risk though. This is EDF squeezing as much profit out of the site as they can.”

Matt Sykes, EDF managing director, said: “Our focus is on continuing to safely deliver the last period of power generation and then transition the station into decommissioning.”

A spokeswoman told the PA news agency the move would give staff clarity and added there would be no immediate job losses because of the phase to defuelling.

Reactors

There are approximately 520 full time EDF Energy employees work at Hunterston B, along with more than 250 full time contract partners.

It comes as the Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) gave EDF permission for Reactor 3 to return to service for a limited period of operation.

Reactor 4 was subsequently returned to service for several months in August 2019 having been one of two remaining reactors at the plant taken out of service the previous year.

The permission is for up to 16.425 Terawatt days, approximately six months’ operation, while the regulatory body is also assessing the safety of Reactor 4 with a decision to be published at a later date.

Safety

Donald Urquhart, ONR deputy chief inspector, said: “This has been a detailed and complex assessment in which my team of specialist inspectors has rigorously assessed and scrutinised the safety case and underpinning evidence provided by EDF NGL.

“This work has taken more than two years, and I am grateful to my team for the diligent and professional manner in which this has been done. I am satisfied that the detailed safety justification provided by the licensee is sufficient to demonstrate that Reactor 3 can operate safely for this period of operation.

“We applied stringent national and international standards when making our decision, have scrutinised the nature of the cracking observed in Reactor 3 and are satisfied that it will not prevent the reactor from operating safely or impede its ability to be shutdown if required during this period of operation.

“As the independent nuclear regulator, our sole priority is the safety of site workers, local residents and the wider public who rely on ONR to regulate such safety matters. We will only allow nuclear facilities to operate if we are satisfied that they are safe to do so.”

This Author

Douglas Barrie is a reporter for PA Scotland.

Help us keep The Ecologist working for the planet

The Ecologist website is a free service, published by The Resurgence Trust, a UK-based educational charity. We work hard - with a small budget and tiny editorial team - to bring you the wide-ranging, independent journalism we know you value and enjoy, but we need your help. Please make a donation to support The Ecologist platform. Thank you!

Donate to us here